5-Minute Peanut Butter Frosting with Natural Peanut Butter
This fluffy peanut butter frosting gets big flavor from creamy, natural peanut butter. Less sweet than most, and made with 5 ingredients! Spread this over teff flour chocolate cake or coconut flour chocolate cake for chocolate peanut butter bliss.
If your peanut butter has oil sitting on top that has separated, give it a good stir before you begin, scraping the sides and bottom of the jar to combine it well.
Combine the butter and powdered sugar in the bowl of a small stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment. (If using a full-size stand mixer, you may need to double the recipe so that there's enough to mix). Alternatively, use a bowl and an electric egg beater or wooden spoon.
Beat together the butter and powdered sugar on medium speed until smooth and creamy, 1 minute.
Scrape down the sides of the bowl and add the peanut butter, vanilla, and salt.
Beat on high speed until the frosting is light and fluffy, 2-3 more minutes, scraping down the sides of the bowl and the paddle once or twice more as needed.
Use the frosting right away, swirled or piped over cake, cupcakes, or brownies. Or cover and keep at cool room temperature until needed, up to 1 day.
Reviews
Colleen on 2026-06-07 (5 stars): I'm not one for natural peanut butter (for day-to-day, I use a no-added-sugar peanut butter but I still need the emulsifier) but I ended up with a jar a few months ago. I specifically looked for a recipe that called for natural peanut butter so I'd have a use for it. I mixed it in the same bowl I'd used for the cake, which still had some batter stuck to the sides so it added a bit of chocolate to the frosting as well. And oh my god is this some tasty frosting! I might have to make it more often just to dip graham crackers or something in.
The only gripe I have is that it's runnier than I expected, but that's almost certainly due to baker error (not only did I mix it with a bit of cake batter, I also used a vegan butter that wasn't QUITE room temp).
Ralph on 2026-04-06 (5 stars): Frosting is delicious! I made it and used it on my homemade sugar free peanut butter cookies (Making them into sandwich cookies between two cookies! I used Monkfruit/Allulose as the sugar replacement - 1:1 for both cookies and peanut butter cream frosting.
Sue on 2026-02-09 (5 stars): Could vegan butter block (or coconut milk as in your chocolate ganache) be used in place of the dairy butter?
Nancy Chew on 2025-12-28 (5 stars): Delicious with Super Moist Chocolate Cake! I wanted to amp up the peanut butter flavor and added 3 Tbsp extra (recipe recs 1-2 Tbsp extra, if desired). My husband loved it so much that he thought he could use it as a daily spread on his GF seed crackers in the morning - that would be very decadent!
Michelle on 2025-12-20 (5 stars): Absolutely love this! I used plant based butter and it was a huge hit with both vegan and non-vegans. My only “complaint” is the portion size is so small. I doubled the recipe and had just enough to make a frosting damn (filled with raspberry jam) and then cover my 7” double layer cake with a very thin layer of frosting. Next time I will triple (maybe quadruple).
Lev on 2025-11-22 (5 stars): I've tried using natural peanut butter for frosting in the past, with generally unsatisfactory (to me) results.
This recipe is not so: I made one small batch, tried it, and immediately realized I needed to double it (& did!)
Gone are the days of not knowing how I'm going to make a good frosting! In are the days of having to restrain myself from eating it all before it makes it to a cake 🤣
- I used salted butter, so I didn't add any extra salt
- I haven't yet tried it with our 'local' natural peanut butter, so it remains to be seen whether or not that specific brand also works.
(I've found I'm not a fan of the texture/somewhat of the taste of that peanut butter :-| but I'm hoping when I get the chance to try it here it'll work out?)
Lisa on 2025-07-17 (5 stars): Canadian. Googled buttercream "icing" made with natural peanut butter. This came up first, so Google knows, that's what matters! We say both icing and frosting interchangeably here in Toronto, but definitely appreciate your consideration <3
Divine on almond flour chocolate cupcakes!
B on 2025-06-15 (5 stars): I made this with salted butter and omg, the salty sweet level was just right. I can’t believe how easy and delicious this recipe was. Definitely a keeper.
Janet on 2025-05-26 (5 stars): THIS IS DELICIOUS. Fun fact: if, like me, you are not a fan of confectioner's sugar frostings, you can always replace that sweetness with a fluff-type product (Dandie's makes a really nice one!) and get a really floofy texture into the bargain, plus fluffernutter points with the PB. Delish and so swoopy and perfect on the teff cake, which I will be making again and again!
PRISCILLA on 2025-03-06 (5 stars): I have a peanut butter Blondie recipe that I like to make but it always seems to be missing something. This frosting is what it was missing. I was a little nervous at first because the Blondie was still warm and so the frosting started to melt when I put it on there. However it ended up being perfect. 2 out of 3 kids loved it (he's not a big fan of peanut butter) and even my husband who always finds something to complain about loved it. 😅 Thanks for sharing this recipe that seems almost too simple to be good. I was very pleasantly surprised.